Can Swans, Dogs, Families And Fishing Co-exist In Sefton Park?

10.06.21 Liverpool Sefton Park male swan & cygnets 037aa 160x115This male swan is father to his six cygnets, now surviving without their mother. The female of the adult pair was lost when a dog attacked her, and the fear is now for the safety of the swan family in her absence. So once again we ask the perennial questions about who our city parks are ‘for’. Can dogs and people mix? And how reasonable is it to permit fishing in this urban environment, given that it too destroys waterbirds and scares away young families?

The upheavals of the past two or three years as Sefton Park was restored are now almost past, and people and some of the resident birds are returning in larger numbers. Surely this is the right time to revisit the rules and determine whose park it most centrally is?

A lung for the city and a park for the people
Sefton Park for most of us serves two main purposes: It is a wonderful green space which helps our crowded city ‘breathe’; and it’s somewhere for everyone to enjoy with others, relaxed in the knowledge that we’re all in a clean and safe place.

The ‘green space’ aspect of the park has been under some strain whilst the renovations were being done. Several hundred mature trees were destroyed so that the park’s Victorian vistas could be regained – a clear victory (despite some good natural conservation practice) for ‘heritage’ over ‘environment’ – the almost inevitable outcome of the influence of heritage-directed funding streams which underpinned the historic park renovations at the expense of modern-day, increasingly pressing, concerns for health and sustainability. And now this same concern for health is under further threat because people are worried about the ever-present unleashed dogs which foul the pathways and grass, presenting a serious public health risk. Plus family park users are worried, if this is not prevented, about the return before long of the presently banished fisher(wo)men.

To date the now-motherless family of swans, so carefully nurtured only a few months ago by the nesting parents, has survived; and we are cautiously hopeful that all will be well for the cygnets. But this year’s sad attack on a swan is not the first time a swan has been killed by dogs in a Liverpool park.

10.07.03 male swan & cygnets ~ Sefton Park Liverpool 027aa 600x380

The grim fate which the mother swan met may be repeated, perhaps on another swan, or unthinkably even as an attack on a child, unless there is better control of dogs.

And surely too the time is right to decide for once and all that fishing, having been banned during Sefton Park’s renovations, may not recommence in this very urban location?

06.05.06 Sefton Park Fishermen

The fishing, and fish, have been moved whilst the park is cleaned up to other more appropriate locations; but fishing should not return when the fish are reinstated into the main lake later this year. In the past we have walked by as horrified children witnessed a waterbird struggling with a swallowed bait hook – another grim scenario not to be repeated.

A place for families and fun
10.07.03 Joanne & Kemmi ~ Anthony Walker Foundation Sefton Park Liverpool 10.07.03 Anthony Walker Foundation ~ Sefton Park Liverpool 10.07.03 Amy & Sam ~ Anthony Walker Foundation Sefton Park Liverpool

Sefton Park has many functions, some social and some more ecological. As the park’s July 2010 Diary of Events shows very well, with weekends of free entertainment such as the Anthony Walker Foundation Festival, it is a place for people of all sorts to meet. Year-round, Sefton Park is where everyone can come to get fit and have fun – whether they want to run, watch the fireworks on Bonfire Night, build a snowman or enjoy the Palm House – almost always, just for the cost of the bus fare.

And with productions like the In The Night Garden theatre as well, in the eyes of our tiniest citizens Sefton Park can even be a place of magic….

10.07.03 In The Night Garden ~ Sefton Park Liverpool

Nothing should stand in the way of this wonderment.

What are parks for?
Let’s acknowledge that fishing and uncontrolled dogs are obstacles which deter some children and families from enjoying the many benefits of our amazing park. We need to insist as our absolute priority that Sefton Park is safe for children and their families to visit.

Along with their vast ‘greening’ impacts, that priority, in human terms, is surely what urban parks are about?

Posted on July 3, 2010, in People And Places, Sustainability As If People Mattered, Travel and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. fishing lines and hooks, ha ha they arnt trying to catch you. And that photograph you have there of the fishermen is a pre arragned match for 4 hours and they are gone by 12pm so they are not there all day. i think is a disgrace that you have tarred all anglers with same brush many of us look after the environment and quite often force dog walkers to put them o na lead which would have prevented the attack on the swan


  3. The Clarke Family

    Does anyone know what has happened to the three missing cygnets on Sefton Park lake?

  4. Here’s an idea… let traffic wardens also be dog (or park) wardens.

    I would hypothesise that the incidence of parking violations is higher during the winter months when people are less willing to walk any distance between their car and their destination. So during summer months at least, when the impact of dogs fouling and running amock in our parks is at its worst, re-allocate some traffic wardens to patrol local parks and defend the rights of non-dog owners to a peaceful and clean experience.

    I fully accept that dogs do need a place to exercise, but this should be in well defined and enclosed areas. And how to identify dogs / owners who violate the rules? Require all dogs to be registered and have a tag / chip which could easily be administered (as they are for cats already) by vet practices at a low cost.

    Traffic wardens do a necessary but not necessarily appreciated job – their dual role would at least earn them appreciation from some people such as myself, the mother of a young child who dreads a nasty interaction with a badly supervised mutt!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: